I have only had bad experiences with DSL. My old provider was (the now out of business) Galaxy Internet Services, and I believe I had IDSL. It was total **** with about 128kbps down and similar up. If anyone was downloading (my lan) it would totally kill the connection. I have Had Comcast cable for a good 3 years now and can only complain about the slow upload speeds. On IRC from a fast dump, I can maintain about 200KB/sec down. and my up caps at around 30 KB/sec. Uploading at more than like 10 KB/sec tends to lag my network. Overall I've had better experiences with cable.
