What is up with the AO forums?
I have noticed since soming to the AO forums that there is a funny thing that goes on here.
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security. Like `how do I set up X Windows in Red Hat' or some other question in the *nix security forum. I am always willing to help out another if I can. I guess that the name *nix security would seem to me to have more things like preventing or detecting root-kits on your *nix box or something like that. In other words the security forums often have only a few posts about security in them. I do respond to these non-security questions if I feel that I can help, but that is just me. I would simply like to see more *security* being discussed on the site.
Tutorials. I have seen tutorials ripped straight from someone else's site, some that I suspect were simply re-written in the posters own words, some that were all original material, and a couple that were just not even helpful or even acurate whether they were plagerized or not. Some posters get away with work that I suspect is not their own, and others get busted on it. Since few of these are really all that good anyway, why not just find some good/accurate ones, clean them up if they need that , and give the original author some or all of the credit (as the case dictates).
`How do i hack [insert exploitable thingy here]?'
Come on now, there are a hundred sites and irc channels where you can get this info. It is like asking 'how do I do a drive by?' 'How do you pick a lock?' `How do you roll a joint?' Not only are these the kind of questions that reflect badly on the poster but on any responders that help out. They just aren't the kind of thing that is appropriate at a site where the intent is to improve the readers knowledge of securing a system or systems. A genuine interest in how a thing is done is a different story though for the prupose of knowledge and a better understanding of security.
Polls. Polls are ok, but how many `What OS?' Polls do we actually need floating around out there? `Should I stay or should I go?' and other such things are alright but I would recommend keeping these to a minimum. A great suggestion on any forum is to look back into the threads pretty far before posting to see if the issue has been covered or not. ( Which I did not do in this case, I felt like bitching and was too lazy to read all the other gripes of the past) I have noticed that when someone does post to an older thread it hits the main page anyway, so it isn't like these get completely buried and forgotten.
Last but not least is flames. I don't think flames are a bad thing as long as the person either had it coming due to a post (perhaps this one? :D) or a reply. Feel free to flame me or even correct me if you care to. On the subject of corrections, be sure and correct the person on something that they actually said. Not the perception of what was said. In short.. Flame/correct away if that is what you like to do, just be sure and have your sh*t together if you come after me. :D
My chief concern here is a potentially useful site, ....maybe.
Re: What is up with the AO forums?
Quote:
Originally posted by psi0nic
I have noticed since soming to the AO forums that there is a funny thing that goes on here.
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security. Like `how do I set up X Windows in Red Hat' or some other question in the *nix security forum. .
I think you'll find that was me. That's right, I posted the thread "How do I install xfree86 under zipslack?"
I can assure you that I will be watching every post you make from now on and if I find any that are not security related you shall know about it.
How dare you come here with your 40 odd posts and question what I have to ask. I seem to remeber you pm'ing me a week or so ago for an Opera crack. I don't think that is very security related.
I suggest you think twice before posting threads that have no real meaning other than increasing the amount of posts you've made...
Re: What is up with the AO forums?
Quote:
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security. Like `how do I set up X Windows in Red Hat' or...
And how much does this have to do with security??? You are just adding garbage to the site with your words here that are full of dead air! If this is to be a security site and you want to hear less chatter about other things then stop posting this crap! Start replying to security issues or posting some SECURITY issues of your own!
Quote:
Tutorials. I have seen tutorials ripped straight from someone else's site, some that I suspect were simply re-written in the posters own words...
First, if you think it's plagerism then prove it. Secondly, if you like to read these so much, then post an informative one of your own and stop whining like a 12 year old AO addict that has had his internet privledges taken away!!!!!!
Quote:
`How do i hack [insert exploitable thingy here]?'
Come on now, there are a hundred sites and irc channels where you can get this info. It is like asking 'how do I do a drive by?' .....understanding of security.
Now you are just rambling, you won't recieve any respect for these meaningless wordy threads that have no meaning!
Quote:
Last but not least is flames. I don't think flames ....
I think you need to invest in a fire extinguisher, although you need to post this in the "I am never satisified" forum.... ask JP to make you one!
Quote:
My chief concern here is a potentially useful site, ....maybe.
If you leave I won't miss you!!!!!! This site is what you make of it, and at the moment I feel as though you aren't making anything of it at all.
Re: What is up with the AO forums?
[QUOTE]Originally posted by psi0nic
Quote:
I have noticed since soming to the AO forums that there is a funny thing that goes on here.
First thing everyone notices these things but we dont rant on about it.....
Quote:
Tutorials. I have seen tutorials ripped straight from someone else's site
I have cut and pasted some tutorials and always given credit, in fact take a look at my tuts and you'll see. I post them because some ppl just browse these forums and dont visit other sites where the tuts may be found.
Quote:
`How do i hack [insert exploitable thingy here]?'
Come on now, there are a hundred sites and irc channels where you can get this info. It is like asking 'how do I do a drive by?' 'How do you pick a lock?' `How do you roll a joint?' Not only are these the kind of questions that reflect badly on the poster but on any responders that help out. They just aren't the kind of thing that is appropriate at a site where the intent is to improve the readers knowledge of securing a system or systems. A genuine interest in how a thing is done is a different story though for the prupose of knowledge and a better understanding of security.
This has been debated so many times, rant rant rant we know, every forum experiances this you are not the first to notice, just ignore what you dislike and focus on what you deem neccesary.
Quote:
Polls. Polls are ok, but how many `What OS?' Polls do we actually need floating around out there? `Should I stay or should I go?' and other such things are alright but I would recommend keeping these to a minimum. A great suggestion on any forum is to look back into the threads pretty far before posting to see if the issue has been covered or not. ( Which I did not do in this case, I felt like bitching and was too lazy to read all the other gripes of the past) I have noticed that when someone does post to an older thread it hits the main page anyway, so it isn't like these get completely buried and forgotten.
Here we go again, heard it all before......
Im not trying to flame you just point out that posts like this will not stop the problem or make us all go, ahhh I never realised we had these problems!
The more rants posted the more distraction from real issues we recieve, if I was not posting to this I would be doing something more constructive or helping someone out but I feel it is a subject that needs to be pointed out to people.
Do not forget. This visitation
Is but to whet thy almost blunted purpose
A Point of Fact and My Opinion
Quote:
Originally posted by cheez_cake
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security. Like `how do I set up X Windows in Red Hat' or...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And how much does this have to do with security??? You are just adding garbage to the site with your words here that are full of dead air! If this is to be a security site and you want to hear less chatter about other things then stop posting this crap! Start replying to security issues or posting some SECURITY issues of your own!
Quote:
Originally posted by RogueSpy
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security.
- psi0nic
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Excuse me! this is the "GENERAL CHITCHAT FORUM" Members can talk about what ever they want to in here. If you want to post
something on security or anything else. . . choose one of the other forums.
This is an excellent example of taking a quote out of context.
Here is the statement in context:
Quote:
Originally posted by psi0nic
Things are often posted that have little or nothing to do with security. Like `how do I set up X Windows in Red Hat' or some other question in the *nix security forum.
From this, it is obvious he was speaking specifically about the security forums, and not the general chit-chat forum. There is no conflict in his statements. He has voiced no complaint about chit-chat in the chit-chat forum.
--
I could not care less about what subjects are posted in any of the forums. I care greatly about my own actions, little about the actions of others. One is most likely to receive a relevant answer to a Unix Security question in the *nix Security forum. I am intelligent enough to understand this concept, and so I seek answers and ask questions in the appropriate places. What more does one need?
