Printable View
Im looking for 3 firewalls and an IDS for my Win2k box.... I have a webserver running mysql..... The firewalls could be free or not, the IDS would have to be free :)
Im looking for software firewalls, not hardware.... I have a few choices of my own but I want to see the AO users top 3
Top 3 firewalls:
1. Tiny
2. NeoWorx/NeoWatch
3. ZoneAlarm
whoops, my last post was a messup... i 4got to put in the IDS :/
Top 3 firewalls:
1. Tiny
2. NeoWorx/NeoWatch
3. ZoneAlarm
IDS:
Snort
i dont have a top 3 , i got a top 2 .... which is the only two i ever used im a newbie icant help it! lol
number one is tiny personal firewall ... i hate to admit it but loony's right , it does own ZA
and number 2 is ZA
My top three (software) firewalls for Win32:
1 Outpost Pro
2 ZoneAlarm Plus/Pro
3 Tied:
-- Tiny PFW 3
-- Sygate PF Pro
IDS: http://www.sourcefire.com/]Snort
I know that many people prefer Tiny and Sygate over ZoneAlarm, but I have personally had very good experiences with ZoneAlarm within a network environment. Also, ZoneLabs tech support has been far superior to that of the other firms, at least in my own, limited, experiences with them.
If you want detailed information on why I prefer one over the other, I'll be more than happy to give you some insight if you PM me.
AJ
blackice defender is top on my list im not 2 sure about everyone else though
Definitly Tiny. It's the best firewall out there I think. Tiny SW came out with an IDS I think, you might investigate that.
I saw your question, I don't have a top 3 software firewall choice,
my 1 (and only) choice would be ...
An old dusty 486 with *nix (or BSD) and IPtables
:cool:
Better than anything else IMHO.
;)
J.
The only experience I have with these is from a support end really. I've not employed a windows OS in my house at present, though it could happen some day... hahahha.. But any how, the list is as follows :
1. Agnitum's OutPost
2. Zone Alarm
3.. Tiny Firewall
4. Sygate
......
....
...
..
.
8. NeoWatch
9. HackTracer
and last but certainly least. effective...
10. Black Ice Defender
The info I have on the software firewalls comes from my background as broadband Tier 3 support. We seem to only see a number of calls that have incidents where someones firewall was breached, and this is the most common occurrence of such incidents. (10 is the worst there is, 1 the best it seems.)
IDS for windoze : I've got nothing as I haven't that much experience with this in the M$ os's
Regards.
edit :
Mcafee and norton fit in the list after 4 somewhere. They are pretty equal in many ways it seems.
Lench - you may want to read some reviews on blackice. The interface is kinda pretty and rather convenient, but as a firewall it is really a joke. Check it out here.
yeaaa IPTABLES is phat.
i liked black ice better than ZA
hands down SNORT
top3 firewalls for windows:
Tiny
Outpost
ZA (I don't like the splash screen)
intrusion detection:
snort is nice
To me, BlackICE is more of an intrusion detection software rather than firewall. Yesterday, Tons Of Fun told us about Kerio Personal firewall, I tried it, and I really, really like it.Quote:
blackice defender is top on my list im not 2 sure about everyone else though
Then the other two: ZoneAlarm Pro and Sygate.
Everyone who mentioned Outpost Pro and snort have given the best answers in my opinion.
top 3 firewall that i been use is:
1) Zone Alarm
2)Outpost pro
3)tiny fiewwall
I have been using AtGuard for a while now, and found it to be excellent. Only problem is that it is pretty hard to get a hold of a legitimate free version.....
Black Ice is also quite good from ISS.
As for an IDS, Snort can do the jab effectively.
hi
look for statefull inspection firewalls not for application firewalls.
conseal ( with w2k patch )
visnetic firewall !
sorry to tell this to others... tiny / zonealarm / outpost, forget it. you dont get the ip packets !
you do not catch it at all . on one machine with tiny and conseal / visnetic , tiny did not recon a outbound conn to a ip adress to chechoslovakia ! well guess ... it was the ip address for a client trojan ( incommand ) .
therfore : lookout for packet filter firewalls
I have only ever used zonealarm, I upgraded to the pro version and I love it, It does everything I need and it seems to be quite powerful.
i'm using lockdown and zonealarm.
running linux or bsd. If we weren't networked to that, I'd choose
1 Sygate Pro
2. Agnitum Outpost
3.Kerio