Anonymous posts

I think it might be something worth considering to add anonymous posts to the system. Somewhere where someone can add something or ask a question that could potentially be embaressing, or they might feel uncomfortable saying in a public forum.

This occured to me when I got a PM from someone, RE: To Report Or Not.., saying that not many would bring a moral dilemna to a public forum. Its a good point, and more people might do that if they could do so anonymously.

It just seems to me that this way people could get feedback on different problems they face, without being embaressed.

The problem arises in that people will post curses and such and expect to get away with it. But the APs could still track back to the person, and the posts could need approval by a moderator before they see the light of day.

What do you all think?

I think it is a good idea, It will bring a lot of cussing, and many unfamily language to the table, nut like you said, it can be handled. I hope Jp seriously thinks about it, and add it along. On the other hand, i don't think he wants to add any new systems, we are having enough problems with the ones that we already have. Good idea though, and congratulation with your acceptence top college a year early, i will soon announce my acceptence 2 years early.lol.

I don't think it would be that great an idea, only because like ebo said. It would bring a lot of undesired problems. I mean, we already have a problem with anonomous bumpers, can you imagine the undesired posts we'd recieve by people who just want to see the regular users loose thier tempers. I think this site would turn into an AOL chatroom if allowed anonomous posters. I just don't think the benifit (although I see it) outweighs the opportunity for disaster and mayhem.

That's just my opinion...I could be wrong --Dennis Miller

Why have that when you can just post your response as hidden. It covers up all the cuss words and it also give peaple a chance to speak their minds.

That's a good idea, but I don't think it stops people from seeing your AO Nick (Does it?). While going to another anonymous message board or creating a new nick is possible, its impractical, and can let people get away with things scot free.

Any other ideas?

Quote:

---

That's a good idea, but I don't think it stops people from seeing your AO Nick (Does it?). While going to another anonymous message board or creating a new nick is possible, its impractical, and can let people get away with things scot free.

Any other ideas?

---

No, it wouldn't stop people from seeing your nic... but if you have a question that you think might damage your reputation or make people dislike you, just get a spare account and ask your ? under a different screen name.

I have to disagree with this idea mobius, the antipoint system and its effects are what make this site what it is. Sorry folks but I support the antipoint system. This would cause more trouble than what it would be worth.

Quote:

---

But the APs could still track back to the person, and the posts could need approval by a moderator before they see the light of day.

---

I have no problems with the AP system, and think it works well for the most part. I just think a forum where people can post things without their identity being seen might be good. APs should still apply, by all means, though. Otherwise, the forum would fall apart pretty quickly.

Why bother assigning AP's at all? The mere idea of posting anon AND still being able to recieve AP's seems well...childish. You should have to take credit and/or blame for what you post on AO. I think assigning AP's to unknown users has a certain undermining quality about it. Also, what's to stop someone from starting a thread, replying to themselves a couple of times in the same thread (anon) with good links and information and all us members here at AO think it's different responses from different members, and now this smart ass gets a bus load of AP's?

ShagDevil, i think we shouldnt here worry about AP's much, we should talk about it bringing quality to the website, or the standard of discussion as a whole.
No offense, but this is what i feel, really.

Also, there is no point in the anonymous posts thing. The very fact that you want to post it anonymously figures that you want to post something that is not ethical. Not always, but mostly.

-inv

antionline is doing good right now.let it go like that.........y to fukk thiz site also .dont ya think so ...hmmmmmm afterall humanmentality never change

wu tang
tommorrow never diezzzzz

This is a security site. What kind of posts would need to posted anonymously to avoid embarrassment?

"I accidentally reformatted my hard drive?"

If that's the case, then you better get over it. When learning about computers and such there is a lot of trial and error and a lot of what is deemed silly questions from people who don't know.

Anything else, such as personal problems, sexuallity, any other issues which may give the need to hide behind an anonymous crutch...really don't belong at AO anyway.

I think AO is fine as it is. You shouldn't even be coming here with posts like "Girl Trouble" or some of the other crappy posts we've seen of late. AO is a security site NOT a place to say whatever's on your mind. An anonymous forum would lead to a hell of a lot of abuse. IMHO, it's not a good idea.
Cheers,
cgkanchi

Hi all.

I think its not such a good idea to allow guests to post for many reasons, (the main reason being the antipoint system. A solution would be to create forums where guests are allowed to post, but not in all the forlums. Also, if they wanna post something thats "embarrasing", just like Greek Godess said, then this is the wrong place todo so. Dont change the current forums, but add forums for issues like this. Let there be forumes for guests, for anything they want, but dont interfeer with the current ones, as they are what makes AO what it is and they are great so far.
Which brings up the following though like some of you have mentioned, its enough work to keep things right as it is, and does JP have the time or the mood to create something for guests.

Let people sign up and be able to participate, and lets keep AO to the subject its always been. Embarrasing subjects that people dont want to post cannot really be computer security related.

Cheers everyone :cool:

I have two words "Anon. Flame", it's a novel idea but if we did this we'd get flame and hate mail all over, also, we COULDNT give the Mod's or even JP the abilety to read who its from or the entire concept of Anonomus is lost.....

it's a good idea, but with a world like this, it will never be realized...sorry.

- Noia