well i think there is an oversight in the implementation. if you look at http://www.antionline.com/showthread...0&pagenumber=1 , you will see that thread commited suicide aparently because of neg's given to a total of 2 posts, which were both by the same user. that doesnt really indicate at all the level of discussion in the thread as a whole. perhaps require that a certian % of the posts in the thread get negs, or(even better) a certian % of the users who have posted in the thread?