well from the point of view of the person posting the thread, yes you can't go wrong with this idea actually, we need to remember that the site isnt all about getting +ve / -Ve AP's, the whole point of the site is to help people sort out their problems if they're appropriate to the site in the first place

It's a very good point which from what i've seen in the forums could be taken onboard by quite a few people

hope this has contributed at least a little to the discussion, plus on a tiny side note this is my first post using Lynx